Distinguishing between the 1st and 2nd generation Apple Pencil involves observing several key features that set these two iterations apart. While both perform the tasks they were designed to do, each version has its characteristics.

If wanderlust beckons, shield your Apple Pencil from the world's rough edges. Invest in a durable Apple Pencil case, a snug Apple Pencil sleeve, or a charming Apple Pencil cover – each a silent sentinel against bumps, slips, and the dreaded "where-did-it-go?!" moment.

apple pencil case 2nd gen

So let's delve into the nuances that help users easily identify which generation of Apple Pencil they own or are considering purchasing.

1. Physical Appearance

1st Generation:

The original Apple Pencil has a sleek cylindrical design with a matte finish. It features a removable cap on one end to access the charging connector. The sleek finish can be a bit slippery at times but the weight of the Pencil makes it easy to hold.

2nd Generation:

The newer model has a more streamlined design, lacking the traditional cap. Instead, it features a flat edge on one side, which helps it attach magnetically to compatible iPad models for charging. The flat edge makes it a bit easier to hold.

2. Charging Method

1st Generation:

Charging the 1st generation Apple Pencil involves removing the cap to reveal a Lightning connector. This connector plugs directly into the Lightning port on the iPad for charging. The Pencil can be vulnerable as it sticks out from the tablet. Always charge in an environment that is safe from potential impacts.

2nd Generation:

The 2nd generation Apple Pencil charges wirelessly by attaching magnetically to the side of compatible iPad Pro models. This not only simplifies the charging process but also provides a secure attachment. Moreover, this eliminates the potential for the Pencil's lighting port to be damaged due to impact while charging.

3. Pairing Process

1st Generation:

The 1st generation Apple Pencil pairs with an iPad via the Lightning connector. Plugging it into the iPad initiates the pairing process. Again, the Pencil can be vulnerable as it sticks out from the tablet during pairing.

2nd Generation:

The 2nd generation Apple Pencil pairs with iPads by attaching magnetically to the device. Once attached, a prompt appears on the iPad screen, simplifying the pairing procedure. Again, this eliminates the potential for the Pencil's lighting port to be damaged due to impact while pairing. 

apple pencil case 2nd gen in black

4. Double-Tap Functionality

1st Generation:

The original Apple Pencil does not have a double-tap feature. Users rely on the single-tap functionality for interacting with the iPad.

2nd Generation:

The 2nd generation Apple Pencil introduces a double-tap feature on its flat side. This customizable feature allows users to switch between tools or perform specific actions within supported apps. If you are a heavy pencil user, this feature alone can be worth the upgrade.

5. Compatibility

1st Generation:

The 1st generation Apple Pencil is compatible with a range of iPad models, including the iPad Pro, iPad (6th and 7th generation), iPad Air (3rd generation), and iPad mini (5th generation).


2nd Generation:

The 2nd generation Apple Pencil is designed specifically for the iPad Pro models released from 2018 onward, featuring the flat-edged design for magnetic attachment and wireless charging.

6. Magnetic Attachment

1st Generation: The original Apple Pencil lacks the magnetic attachment capability found in the 2nd generation. It relies on the Lightning connector for both charging and connectivity.

2nd Generation

The 2nd generation Apple Pencil easily attaches magnetically to the side of compatible iPads, ensuring a secure connection and convenient storage.

7. Pricing

1st Generation:

Generally, the 1st generation Apple Pencil is available at a lower price point compared to the 2nd generation.

2nd Generation:

The 2nd generation Apple Pencil, being the latest iteration with added features, is priced higher than its predecessor.

What Are The Differences Between the 1st-Gen and 2nd-Gen Apple Pencil?

Distinguishing between the 1st and 2nd generation Apple Pencil is relatively straightforward. The 1st generation has a sleek cylindrical design with a removable cap and charges via a Lightning connector.

In contrast, the 2nd generation features a flat edge, lacks a removable cap, and charges wirelessly by attaching magnetically to compatible iPads. The 2nd generation also introduces a double-tap feature on its flat side for added functionality, while the 1st generation does not have this capability.

Additionally, the 2nd generation is specifically designed for use with iPad Pro models released from 2018 onward, showcasing a more streamlined and modern appearance compared to its predecessor.

Observing these physical and functional differences can help users easily identify which generation of Apple Pencil they own or are considering purchasing.

By considering these distinct characteristics, users can confidently identify whether they possess a 1st or 2nd generation Apple Pencil, enabling them to make informed decisions regarding compatibility and functionality with their iPad models.

maccase magnetic accessory system with case for apple pencil

Jody K. Deane
by Jody K. Deane December 19, 2023
Tags: pencil case

Leave a comment

Please note: comments must be approved before they are published.